Why Perfection Is Overrated and Proof Is Everything

In a fast-paced, results-driven world, flashy promises often drown out the quiet power of authenticity. Yet, whether you're marketing a product or devising a business strategy, the rule remains the same: don’t just promise, prove.

Let’s unpack this with a bit of humour. Imagine a razor blade advertisement. More often than not, the blade is shown gliding effortlessly across an already smooth surface - zero challenge, zero stakes.

But what if the ad aimed higher? What if it showcased the product tackling a real challenge, like shaving a gorilla?

Okay, let’s not take this literally. But the metaphor is powerful. It highlights the importance of demonstrating value in the toughest, most real-life scenarios. After all, polished, easy wins might look good in a presentation, but what truly resonates with your audience is grit, proof, and authenticity. Read the Linkedin post here.

Why Authenticity Matters in Strategy

A LinkedIn user nailed it with a comment:

This insight applies beyond product marketing—it’s critical in business strategy. Strategies are often presented as glossy, one-size-fits-all plans that promise perfection. Yet, in reality, successful strategies are tested and proven in the messiness of real-life challenges.

What does this mean for your business? 

It’s simple:

• Stop painting rosy pictures. Build a strategy that works in real conditions, not just on paper.

• Show the work. Don’t hide behind buzzwords—demonstrate real, measurable outcomes.

How to Build “Gorilla-Tested” Strategies

• Identify the Real Challenge Every business faces unique obstacles. Don’t sidestep them—embrace them. Whether it’s navigating supply chain disruptions, adapting to market trends, or handling customer complaints, your strategy should focus on solving real problems.

  
  

• Test Your Ideas in Tough Scenarios Just like the razor needs to prove it can handle thick gorilla fur, your strategy needs to withstand pressure. Run pilot programs, seek feedback, and adapt based on the results.

• Keep It Honest It’s tempting to dress up your strategy to make it look flawless. But stakeholders value transparency. They’d rather hear, “Here’s what we’ve tried, what worked, and what didn’t” than “We’ve got it all figured out.”

• Measure and Show the Proof Talk is cheap. Prove your strategy’s effectiveness with data and real-world results. Share case studies, testimonials, and measurable impacts that show your approach works.

The Pitfall of Perfection

Striving for perfection is a trap that even the most seasoned leaders can fall into. It starts innocently enough: the desire to account for every variable, eliminate all risk, and ensure the strategy is flawless before execution. While this sounds admirable, it often leads to analysis paralysis, where decisions are delayed, momentum is lost, and opportunities pass by unnoticed.

Why does this happen?

Perfectionism in strategy stems from a fear of failure. Leaders worry about the potential for missteps, criticism, or unforeseen challenges. In an attempt to safeguard against these risks, they overanalyse data, continuously tweak plans, and seek out unattainable levels of certainty.

However, business environments rarely allow the luxury of perfection. Markets evolve rapidly, competition intensifies, and external factors like economic shifts or technological advancements can derail even the best-laid plans. In these dynamic conditions, a good strategy executed with agility and adaptability is far more valuable than a so-called “perfect” strategy that never sees the light of day.

Consider the razor blade that glides effortlessly over a hairless face in adverts. It looks perfect, sleek, and efficient, but it doesn’t tell us much about how the product performs under real-world conditions.

Will it handle a thick beard? Coarse hair? The unpredictability of actual use?

In the same way, a strategy that appears flawless on paper can fail when faced with real-world complexities.

For example:

• A new product launch might be meticulously planned, but unforeseen supply chain disruptions could render those plans useless.

• A team restructuring could look efficient on a flowchart but fail to account for the human challenges of adapting to change.

Without stress-testing the strategy in real scenarios - like the metaphorical challenge of shaving a gorilla - it’s impossible to gauge its true effectiveness.

Practicality: The Secret Sauce of Great Strategy

What sets effective strategies apart isn’t just innovation - it’s practicality. A razor that handles thick, tough hair isn’t just impressive; it’s useful. Similarly, a strategy that works seamlessly in real-world conditions isn’t just clever on paper; it’s actionable in practice. It bridges the gap between theoretical brilliance and practical implementation, making it the driving force behind sustained success.

Practicality ensures that your strategy can handle challenges, adapt to evolving needs, and deliver consistent results. It’s not about creating something that sounds impressive in a presentation but about crafting a solution that works where it truly matters - on the ground, in the hands of users, and in the face of real-world complexities.

Here’s what practicality entails:

Understanding the end-user

Whether your end-user is a customer or a team within your organisation, the usability of your strategy is paramount. A strategy that’s impractical or overly complex can alienate its users, leading to frustration and poor adoption rates. It’s essential to consider how the people who will interact with your strategy think, work, and respond to changes.

To ensure usability:

• Invest time in understanding the unique needs, preferences, and pain points of your end-users.

• Involve them early in the strategic planning process to gather insights and secure buy-in.

• Simplify complex processes without oversimplifying the solution—strike a balance between clarity and functionality.

A razor designed for a specific hair type won’t work for everyone; similarly, a one-size-fits-all strategy is rarely effective. Tailoring your approach to your audience ensures your strategy isn’t just a vision—it’s a roadmap they can follow.

Focusing on outcomes Practical strategies keep the endgame in sight. They’re not just about ticking off tasks or meeting arbitrary milestones but delivering tangible, measurable benefits.

Every element of the strategy should answer two critical questions:

• What problem does this solve?

• How does it unlock value for the organisation, the team, or the customer?

Focusing on outcomes requires:

• Clearly defining the desired results at the outset. This creates a benchmark for success and keeps efforts aligned with goals.

• Establishing metrics to measure progress and impact. What gets measured gets managed.

• Ensuring each step of the strategy contributes meaningfully to the bigger picture. Eliminate activities that don’t add value or move the needle.

For example, a razor that claims to offer the “smoothest shave ever” needs to prove it can consistently deliver that outcome. Similarly, your strategy must demonstrate its ability to produce the results it promises - whether that’s boosting sales, improving efficiency, or enhancing customer satisfaction.

The Takeaway: Proof Over Promises

The message is clear: in both marketing and strategy, it’s not about how perfect you make things look. It’s about demonstrating real value through real challenges.

So, ask yourself:

• Is my strategy razor-sharp, or is it skating over hairless surfaces?

• Have I tested it in challenging, real-life scenarios?

• Am I showing stakeholders proof of its success, or just selling them the promise?

As one commenter aptly put it:

The next time you’re tempted to craft the perfect pitch, remember: your audience doesn’t want perfection - they want proof. And proof comes from facing challenges head-on, whether that’s shaving a gorilla or building a strategy that works when the stakes are high.

Practicality turns ideas into impact. It’s the difference between a strategy that inspires and one that delivers. So, as you refine your next plan, ask yourself:

Is this actionable?

Does it solve real problems?

Most importantly, can it withstand the challenges ahead?

Don’t let your strategy remain a theoretical masterpiece - put it to the test, adapt it, and make it work where it counts. Need help turning vision into action?

Let’s connect and build strategies that get results.

Connect with us to support your strategy to dominate!

Subscribe to our Newsletter.