Beyond Price: The Value Stick Approach to Adding Value

In today’s highly competitive business environment, relying on pricing alone is no longer an effective way to differentiate products or services. Customers are not merely looking for the cheapest option; they are seeking value - a multifaceted concept that can provide a game-changing advantage for organisations aiming to scale or solidify their market position. This is where the "value stick" concept comes into play.

The "value stick" is a visual framework that illustrates the various components that contribute to the overall value from both the customer’s and the business’s perspectives. Understanding how to expand each part of the value stick can lead to strategic advantages, greater customer loyalty, and long-term success.

But what exactly is this additional value, and how can organisations offer more than just competitive pricing?

The Price Factor: Where Most Companies Begin

At its simplest level, price is one of the easiest elements for customers to evaluate. For many years, businesses have relied on pricing strategies to attract and retain customers, often lowering prices to undercut competitors or creating pricing tiers for different market segments.

However, a price-focused approach only works to a point. Lowering prices may attract initial interest, but it rarely fosters long-term loyalty or creates a sustainable competitive advantage. Competitors can easily offer something cheaper, or sudden shifts in the economy can undermine your pricing strategy - and even lead to demise.

The real opportunity lies beyond price - in delivering a broader and more impactful concept of value.

Introducing the "Value Stick" Concept

The "value stick" framework breaks value down into distinct layers, helping organisations understand what customers are truly seeking. Read the full article from Harvard Business School here.

It consists of four key components:

1. Willingness to Pay (WTP)

2. Price

3. Cost

4. Willingness to Sell (WTS)

Each layer can be adjusted to create more perceived value and profitability, but the real transformation happens by expanding the parts that don’t directly involve lowering the price.

1. Willingness to Pay (WTP): Increasing What Customers Are Willing to Pay

At the top of the value stick is Willingness to Pay (WTP) - the maximum amount a customer is prepared to pay for a product or service. Raising WTP doesn’t mean inflating the price, but offering additional value that justifies a higher spend.

To increase WTP, organisations can:

• Enhance the customer experience: Delivering a seamless, enjoyable journey - from product discovery to post-purchase support - encourages customers to pay more for the added convenience.

• Provide tailored solutions: Offering personalisation or customisation allows customers to feel that the product or service is uniquely suited to them, adding a premium quality that competitors may find difficult to replicate.

• Focus on branding and perception: Strong brands with positive associations - such as trust, innovation, or exclusivity - can command higher prices. Think of brands like Apple or Tesla.

By focusing on WTP, you ensure that customers aren’t just purchasing a product or service - they’re buying an experience, a solution, or even an identity. This reduces price sensitivity and fosters greater customer loyalty.

2. Price: Setting It Correctly Without Relying on Discounts

Price, positioned between WTP and cost, is where many businesses focus. However, instead of lowering prices to undercut competitors, savvy organisations use the value stick to create a perception of value that justifies their pricing.

Your pricing should reflect the total value provided to the customer. A common mistake is engaging in price wars, reducing prices while simultaneously diminishing the perceived quality or benefits. The goal should be to offer a price that reflects the entire customer experience, the product’s benefits, and the after-sales services provided.

3. Cost: Managing Costs Efficiently

Reducing costs while maintaining quality is another way to adjust the value stick. This doesn’t mean cutting corners but rather optimising processes, using technology, or negotiating better deals with suppliers. Organisations that lower costs without compromising on quality can reinvest the savings to create additional value for customers, which in turn increases WTP.

For example, using automation or artificial intelligence can lower operational costs, enabling companies to offer additional services or faster delivery times at no extra charge. This increases customers' perception of value, potentially raising WTP, even as costs decrease.

4. Willingness to Sell (WTS): Understanding the Minimum You’re Willing to Accept

At the bottom of the value stick is Willingness to Sell (WTS) - the minimum amount your organisation is willing to accept to bring your product or service to market. Lowering WTS involves finding ways to improve efficiency and reduce production or service costs.

Forward-thinking companies are finding ways to stretch this part of the value stick by improving supply chain management, investing in employee training, or adopting lean manufacturing principles. The more efficient and effective the backend of your business is, the more you can reduce WTS and improve margins.

Value Beyond Price: Building Log Term Relationships

The value stick framework prompts businesses to move beyond price-driven strategies and concentrate on building relationships founded on genuine value. These true value propositions extend beyond financial aspects, delivering an experience that resonates with the customer.

Find these customer-resonating elements! A strategy that serves the customers...

When businesses focus on creating meaningful, non-financial value - whether through superior service, product innovation, or customer experience - the result is a narrative that customers willingly share. This level of value not only enhances satisfaction but also organically promotes the service or product, as the value created becomes its own best advocate, driving word-of-mouth referrals and brand loyalty.

Here are some ways to expand value in ways that create lasting customer loyalty:

• After-sales support and customer service: Excellent customer service can create lifetime customers, even when problems arise. Customers appreciate knowing they are supported beyond the initial purchase.

• Ease of Transaction: Simplifying the purchasing process can significantly improve the customer experience. Whether it’s through a streamlined online checkout process, clear and easy-to-follow instructions, or offering multiple payment options, making transactions effortless creates a frictionless experience. Customers appreciate convenience and are more likely to return to a brand that saves them time and hassle.

• Personalisation: Tailoring products, services, or communications to meet individual customer preferences can significantly enhance the perceived value. Personalised experiences, such as customised product options or targeted offers based on past behaviour, make customers feel valued and understood. This deeper connection creates emotional loyalty, leading to repeat purchases and positive recommendations.

• Corporate social responsibility (CSR): Many customers are willing to pay more for products or services from companies that demonstrate ethical practices and social responsibility. Whether it’s reducing your environmental footprint or supporting community initiatives, CSR efforts can increase WTP.

• Community Engagement: Building a sense of community around your brand, whether through social media engagement, user forums, or events, helps customers feel part of something bigger. Encouraging dialogue, sharing customer stories, and facilitating peer support can create a loyal group of advocates who identify with the brand's mission or values. This sense of belonging adds value that transcends the product or service itself.

• Transparency and Trust: Being open about business practices, pricing structures, or the sourcing of materials builds trust. Customers are more likely to remain loyal to a company that is honest, even when mistakes are made, as transparency fosters credibility. Providing clear information on issues such as delivery timelines, data protection, or product origin strengthens the customer relationship by building confidence in the brand.

• Innovation: Continuously improving and introducing new features, even small ones, keeps your product or service fresh and desirable. Customers will always pay more for innovative solutions that solve unique problems or provide a better overall experience.

The companies that thrive in today’s market are not those focusing solely on price. Instead, they are the ones who master the art of value creation. By understanding and applying the value stick concept, you can identify ways to expand value at every point - whether through raising WTP, managing costs, or providing unmatched customer experiences.

Ultimately, it’s not just about what your product or service costs - it’s about what it’s worth to your customers. Strategic value creation fosters loyalty, strengthens brands, and drives sustainable business growth.

Subscribe here to our newsletter to get insights into strategy, leadership, and the latest trends.